Judging CAST’s 7th Annual North Fork Festival of Trees

On Thursday, the ladies of NOFO LIVE had the honor of judging CAST’s 7th Annual North Fork Festival of Trees inside the historic barn at Treiber Farms, which kicks off tonight with the sponsors’ preview before opening to the public all weekend, November 21 and 22.
Walking the floor with our official judging binders was both magical and nearly impossible. We were blown away by the craftsmanship and local personality packed into every design, from Daniel Gale’s "Deck the Shelves" display, a tree reimagined as a giant fish on Santa’s fishing pole, and a “Knicks in Five” tree complete with courtside seats and a rack of jerseys.
While the three of us approached our binders a little differently, we all felt the same tug of holiday emotion trying to narrow down our picks.
“It was truly an honor to be invited to judge this year's Festival of Trees and Wreaths,” Sunita said. “But I have to say, choosing one winner over another was incredibly difficult! So much thought, creativity, love and personal investment goes into every single tree and wreath, and that effort is priceless. Each one tells its own story and reflects the generosity of the people behind it. More than anything, the experience reminded me how fortunate we are to live in a community that shows up, gives so generously and is always ready to support one another. That's what makes the North Fork so special.”
For Tracy, who chaired the event several years ago right after her daughter Tilly was born (and says Tilly is already excited to come back this weekend to give Santa her wish list!), the structured five-part scoring and the sheer teamwork behind the scenes stood out most.
“What I really loved about the process was that you walk in with an immediate reaction, and then the judging criteria are so well thought out that I was actually surprised by which one I rated the highest,” Tracy shared on Friday morning's show. “As the event planner of the group, I also want to give a huge shout-out to Treiber Farms for donating their space every year and to the CAST team and volunteers. I know how much pre-coordination goes into getting all the designers in there, the lights, the garland, the tents, and transforming the property. With the barns, the outdoor seating, the heaters and the fire pits, it truly looks like a Hallmark movie.”

While our official judge ballots are locked in, everyone who visits on Saturday and Sunday gets a vote in the People’s Choice Awards. Even better, every decorated piece in the barn (along with all the gifts and experiences tucked underneath) is up for auction, and volunteer elves deliver the winning trees straight to your home!
Bid on Our NOFO LIVE Mahjong Auction Basket!
We didn’t just show up with our judging clipboards this year. We also put together our very own NOFO LIVE "Check In & Tile Out" Mahjong Basket (Item #301, valued at $875) for the silent auction! If you have been following along with our monthly NOFO LIVE mahjong gatherings all year, you already know how much fun this community has had learning and playing together. Here is what is inside our basket up for bid right now:
A Complete Mahjong Set: Perfect whether you are looking for your own set or gifting one to a friend who is learning to play.
Four (4) Tickets to a Future NOFO LIVE Mahjong Open Play Event: Bring your favorite table of four to join us at an upcoming gathering!
$500 Gift Certificate Toward a Stay at The Harvest Inn: Generously donated by our friends at The Harvest Inn in Peconic. If you have never experienced their historic bed-and-breakfast, the three-course breakfast alone (complete with fresh juice shots!) is legendary, and their wraparound porch is practically begging for an afternoon mahjong game.

What Else Is New at the Barn This Year
On Friday morning’s live episode of NOFO LIVE (our first broadcast with all three of us co-hosting together!), we caught up with CAST Executive Director Erica Steindl and the festival team live from the barn, where they shared several exciting highlights and new additions for 2026:
Debut of the New CAST Food Truck: The organization is officially launching its brand-new CAST Food Truck this weekend! Staffed by their culinary team and graduates of the North Fork Culinary Program, the truck is serving desserts at tonight’s preview party and rolling out upscale fair food all weekend alongside the baked goods and hot cocoa at the Cookie Cottage.
Live Holiday Music & Extended Santa Hours: Local singing groups will perform traditional holiday songs throughout the weekend, and Santa will have extended hours on both Saturday and Sunday for photos and wish lists (plus the vintage white pickup truck outside for photo ops, along with ornament decorating, crafts and face painting in Santa’s Workshop).
Tree, Wreath & Silent Auctions (Open now through Monday at 6 PM!): Alongside our NOFO LIVE Mahjong basket, the silent auction is already live online and features a 3-day Skip Barber Racing School package, a private party for 50 with the Rolling in the Dough pizza truck, a private performance by Ethel’s Mermen, North Fork and South Fork overnight stays, and original works donated by local artists. Bidding stays open until Monday, November 23 at 6:00 PM, so you can take your time soaking up the displays in person.
As CAST’s largest fundraiser of the year, every admission ticket, auction bid, Merry Marketplace purchase and Cookie Cottage treat directly supports the Center for Advocacy, Support & Transformation as they assist North Fork and Shelter Island neighbors with food relief, heating oil and rental aid, and educational programs heading into the winter months.
CAST’s 7th Annual North Fork Festival of Trees
Where: Treiber Farms, 38320 County Road 48, Peconic, NY 11958
Weekend Hours:
Saturday, November 21: 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM
Sunday, November 22: 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM
Admission: $10 Adults | $5 Seniors & Kids (ages 6+) | Free for Kids 5 & under
Online Bidding: Silent auction is live now (and tree/wreath bidding opens tonight) through Monday, Nov 23 at 6:00 PM via castnorthfork.org (FestofTrees26.givesmart.com)
Holiday Toy Drive: Guests are also invited to bring a new, unwrapped toy for the CAST Holiday Toy Drive!




Comments